Countertop Budgeting Guide: What to Know Before Replacing Countertops
Replacing your countertops is one of the most impactful upgrades you can make in your kitchen or bathroom. It transforms the look of your home, increases functionality, and can significantly boost resale value. But when it comes to budgeting, many homeowners underestimate the true cost of countertop replacement — not because contractors hide fees, but because there are many components people don’t think about until they’re already deep in the process.
This comprehensive Countertop Budgeting Guide breaks down every factor that influences price, the hidden costs people often overlook, and the exact questions to ask during your showroom visit. Whether you’re planning your first renovation or comparing quotes between fabricators, this guide ensures you walk in confident, informed, and ready to make the smartest investment.
Why Is Countertop Budgeting Important
Countertops are priced differently than most home upgrades. It’s not just about the material cost — the breakdown includes fabrication, installation, edge profiles, cutouts, delivery, and sometimes structural reinforcement.
Understanding each category helps you:
- Compare quotes fairly
- Avoid surprise charges
- Select materials that fit your lifestyle and your budget
- Plan upgrades that enhance long-term home value
- Determine where it’s worth spending and where you can save
At Masters Countertops, we pride ourselves on transparency, in-stock material pricing, and educating homeowners before any commitment. This guide is an extension of that approach — giving you everything you need to budget confidently.
Understanding the Base Cost: Material + Fabrication
When homeowners search “How much do countertops cost in Chicagoland?”, they’re usually referring to the primary price factor: material cost per square foot.
Common pricing tiers:
- Entry-level granite or quartz: $35–$55/sq.ft.
- Mid-range quartz or premium granite: $55–$75/sq.ft.
- Quartzite & higher-end quartz: $80–$130/sq.ft.
- Ultra-premium stones & rare materials: $140+/sq.ft.
This base cost typically includes:
- Slab selection
- Digital laser measurement (templating)
- Fabrication
- Standard edges
- Installation
However, this doesn’t cover everything. The sections below highlight what can increase your total price and what you can avoid with smart planning.
Hidden Countertop Costs Homeowners Don’t Expect
These aren’t “extra fees.” They are legitimate parts of the fabrication process, but many homeowners simply don’t know to ask about them. Awareness helps you budget accurately and compare quotes apples-to-apples.
Sink Cutouts
Cutouts vary in price based on:
1. Sink Type
- Undermount sinks (most popular): usually the highest cost
- Drop-in sinks: lower cost
- Farmhouse sinks: require additional support and fabrication labor
2. Finish Style
- Polished cutout edges (visible): higher cost
- Unpolished (for drop-in sink): lower cost
3. Number of Sinks
Kitchen, prep sink, laundry sink — each needs its own cutout.
Faucet Holes
Faucet holes are minor but add up depending on how many you need.
You may need holes for:
- Faucet
- Soap dispenser
- Filtered water tap
- Instant hot water faucet
- Air gap (dishwasher)
Most homeowners are surprised they need 3–5 holes, not just one.
Cooktop or Range Cutouts
Cooktop cutouts require significant labor because:
- Corners must be reinforced
- The stone is structurally weakened
- Special tools are used to prevent cracking
Ranges do not require cutouts, but may require filling gaps or shimming.
Mitered Edge Upgrades
Mitered edges create a thicker, luxurious look, especially on islands.
They are used when:
- You want a 2.5–4” thick island edge
- You want a waterfall edge
- You want a fully integrated modern slab look
These require premium fabrication, precise craftsmanship, and more materials.
Edge Profile Upgrades
Standard edges include:
- Flat/Eased edge
Premium edges cost more:
- Ogee
- Bullnose
- Mitered
- Dupont
- Waterfall edges
Tip to Save: Stick with eased edges in bathrooms or laundry rooms.
Removal & Disposal
Removing your old countertops takes:
- Labor
- Proper disposal
- Extra time if you have tile or heavy solid-surface materials
Ask whether this is included in your quote or separate.
Leveling or Cabinet Adjustments
Stone countertops must be installed on a level, properly supported surface to prevent stress points and future cracking. If your cabinets or island base are uneven, any required leveling, reinforcement, or structural adjustments must be completed prior to templating or installation.
Note: Masters Countertops does not provide cabinet leveling, shimming, or structural corrections. These services fall under carpentry and must be handled by your contractor before we can proceed.
Long-Distance Travel or Access Fees
These fees apply if:
- Your home is far from the fabrication shop
- Your building has difficult access (high-rise elevators, long carrying distance)
Masters Countertops always informs customers in advance if these apply.
Small Project Fee (Below 35 sq.ft.)
Small projects often cost more per square foot because:
- The templating and fabrication process stays the same
- Material yield is less efficient
- Delivery and installation still require a full crew
This is common for bathroom vanities, laundry rooms, mudrooms, and bar tops.
How Material Choice Impacts Overall Budget
Different materials have different long-term value.
- Low maintenance
- Most consistent pricing
- Vast color selection
- Ideal for busy households
- Durable and heat resistant
- Unique patterns
- Needs sealing
- Luxury natural stone
- Extremely durable
- Higher cost
- Interior designers love it
- Elegant and timeless
- Higher maintenance
- Best for low-use spaces
How to Create a Realistic Countertop Budget
A healthy budget should include:
A. Material Cost (usually includes Fabrication and Installation)
60–70% of total
B. Hidden or Additional Items
10–20% of total
C. Contingency Buffer
5–10% for unexpected adjustments
Countertop Budget-Saving Strategies
Here are smart ways to stay within budget without sacrificing quality:
1. Choose In-Stock Materials
In-stock slabs save hundreds because:
- No freight costs
- No special ordering
- Better availability for remnants
- Faster turnaround
Masters Countertops has one of Chicagoland’s largest in-stock collections.
2. Use Remnants for Small Areas
Perfect for:
- Bathrooms
- Laundry rooms
- Bar tops
- Fireplace hearths
You can get premium stone for a fraction of the cost.
3. Skip Premium Edge Profiles
Stick with:
- Eased
- Pencil
Save mitered edges and waterfalls for main islands.
4. Keep Layout Simple
Avoid extra seams, cutouts, curves, or extensions.
5. Avoid Moving Appliances or Plumbing
These upgrades multiply costs beyond countertops.
Questions to Ask During Your Countertop Showroom Visit
Use this checklist to compare quotes and ensure transparency.
Material Questions
- Is this material in-stock or special order?
- Are there additional expenses for maintenance?
- Can I view the exact slab before fabrication?
Fabrication Questions
- What edge profiles are included?
- Does the price include a digital template?
- How long is the fabrication timeline?
- Are mitered edges extra?
Installation Questions
- Is removal included?
- Is disposal included?
- Are sink cutouts and faucet holes included in the quote?
- What is the cost for additional holes?
- Is the cooktop cutout included?
Home-Specific Questions
- Will my cabinets need leveling?
- Do I need extra support for overhangs?
- Are there distance or access fees?
Budget Questions
- What is NOT included in this quote?
- Are there fees for small projects (under 35 sq.ft.)?
- Are there long-distance or high-rise fees?
- What payment schedule do you require?
When to Spend More — and When You Can Save
Worth the Upgrade
- Islands
- Kitchens used daily
- Homes you plan to sell
- Quartzite or premium quartz
Places to Save
- Laundry rooms
- Guest bathrooms
- Bar top accents
- Remnant-based projects
Final Thoughts
A countertop project seems simple but in reality, countertop budgeting involves many small decisions that can greatly affect the total cost. The good news? With the right information, you can avoid surprises and invest confidently.
At Masters Countertops, our goal is transparency. We walk you through material options, show you real slabs, explain cutout costs, review layout details, and help you avoid unnecessary expenses. From in-stock quartz and granite to premium quartzite, we offer honest pricing and expert guidance every step of the way.
Ready to start planning?
Visit our Wheeling showroom or request a free quote online.
Let’s create a countertop design that fits your home and your budget.
Like what you see? Follow us for more design inspiration, expert tips, and the latest trends in natural stone and quartz countertops. Don’t forget to share!